Most people learn to judge investments by their average return. In retirement, that number can be misleading. Once you start withdrawing money, the order in which returns arrive can matter as much as how big they are. That’s sequence-of-returns risk.
Same average, different outcome
Picture two retirees. Each starts with $1,000,000 and withdraws $50,000 a year. Over five years, both portfolios earn the exact same set of returns: −20%, −10%, +10%, +15%, and +25%. The only difference is the order.
| Year | Retiree A (bad years first) | Retiree B (good years first) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | −20% | +25% |
| 2 | −10% | +15% |
| 3 | +10% | +10% |
| 4 | +15% | −10% |
| 5 | +25% | −20% |
Both portfolios have the same average return. But Retiree A sold shares to fund withdrawals while prices were down. Those shares weren’t there for the rebound. Retiree B withdrew from a growing portfolio, so the later losses hit a larger, healthier balance.
Assuming each year’s withdrawal comes out at the start of the year, Retiree A ends with roughly $797,000. Retiree B ends with roughly $920,000. Same returns, same withdrawals, about $123,000 apart after just five years. Over a 25- or 30-year retirement, the gap can decide whether the money lasts.
Averages describe the market. Sequences describe your retirement.
Why withdrawals change the math
While you’re saving and not withdrawing, the order of returns doesn’t change the ending value of a lump sum. Multiplication works in any order: a −20% year followed by a +25% year leaves you exactly where you started, either way.
Withdrawals break that symmetry. Each time you sell investments to cover expenses, you take shares out of the portfolio permanently. Selling after a drop means selling more shares to raise the same dollars. Those shares can’t take part in any recovery.
This is why the years just before and just after retirement get so much attention. A large decline then can do outsized damage, and a decline 15 years in usually does far less.
Common ways people manage it
Nobody can control the order of market returns. But there are widely discussed ways to reduce how much a bad sequence can hurt. Each comes with trade-offs.
- A cash or bond reserve. Some retirees keep one to three years of spending in lower-volatility assets. That way they aren’t forced to sell stocks during a downturn.
- Flexible withdrawals. Spending a bit less after a bad year, rather than a fixed inflation-adjusted amount every year, can noticeably improve how long a portfolio lasts.
- Adjusting the stock/bond mix around retirement. Reducing volatility in the “red zone” years, then letting the mix drift back over time, is one approach researchers have studied.
- Guaranteed income sources. Social Security, pensions, and some annuities provide income that doesn’t depend on market timing. That reduces how much has to come from the portfolio.
What this means for you
Sequence-of-returns risk is a big reason why a simple rule like “average 7% a year” isn’t a retirement plan. If you’re within about ten years of retirement, it’s worth understanding how your withdrawals would work in a bad first few years, not just an average one.
The concepts here are general education. How much risk you can tolerate, and which tools fit, depends on your income needs, other assets, taxes, and health. For a decision like that, a licensed financial professional can model your specific situation.
Frequently Asked Questions.
What is sequence-of-returns risk in simple terms?
It's the risk that poor investment returns arrive early in retirement, while you are also withdrawing money. Selling investments after a drop locks in losses and leaves fewer shares to recover, so the same average return can leave you with much less money than if the bad years had come later.
Does sequence-of-returns risk matter before retirement?
Much less. While you are still contributing and not withdrawing, the order of returns does not change your ending balance from a one-time investment. It starts to matter most in the years just before and after you begin making withdrawals, sometimes called the retirement 'red zone.'
How do people try to reduce sequence-of-returns risk?
Common approaches include holding a cash or bond reserve to draw from during downturns, using flexible withdrawal rules that spend less after bad years, and gradually adjusting the stock/bond mix around the retirement date. Each involves trade-offs, and the right mix depends on your situation — a licensed professional can help you weigh them.
Written by
Author Name
Staff Writer
PLACEHOLDER — replace with a 1–2 sentence bio describing this writer's background and what they cover. Bios with real, verifiable experience help readers (and search engines) trust the content.
Reviewed by
Reviewer Name, Credentials (e.g., CFP®)
Financial Reviewer
PLACEHOLDER — replace with the reviewer's credentials and experience. Only list designations the reviewer actually holds.
Last reviewed